LA NPDT: LA New Product Development Team
About Us
  • Info & History
  • Testimonials
  • Careers & Internships
  • FAQ
Services
  • Product Discovery
  • Product Design
  • Industrial Design
  • Prototyping
  • Silicone Rubber
  • Manufacturing
  • Research
  • Consulting
  • View All
Our Work
  • Personal Care
  • Pet Products
  • Sports & Fitness
  • Product Packaging
  • IoT & Consumer
  • Medical Devices
  • Industrial Equipment
  • Food & Beverage
  • Toys & Games
  • Home & Housewares
  • Baby & Juvenile
  • Outdoor & Hunting
  • Funded Startups & Grants
  • SBIR & Grant-Funded Projects
  • Health & Wellness
  • All Projects
Insights
  • Articles
  • Best Product Development Companies
  • Best Product Design Companies
  • Best Invention Help Companies
  • Medical Device Design Companies
  • Best Prototyping Companies
  • Prototype Development Companies
  • Product Engineering Companies
  • Product Development in Louisiana
  • YouTube Channel
  • Market Reports
Tools
  • Product Name Generator
  • Free US Trademark Search
  • AI Invention Idea Analyzer
  • US Patent Search
  • AI Product Idea Generator
  • Prototype Cost Calculator
  • Product Design Cost Calculator
  • AI Prototype Engineer
  • All free tools
Contact Us
  • Contact us
  • Book a consultation
  • Request a quote
  • Apply to Partner with Us
318-200-0526Apply to Partner

Let’s build
your next product.

Apply to Partner→

Awards and Recognitions

  • Google Reviews★★★★★5.0 (45 Reviews)
  • Shopify Top Product Development FirmTop Product Development Firm
  • Entrepreneur 360 Top Product Development CompanyEntrepreneur's 360 Top Product Development Company
  • BBB Accredited Business★★★★★A+ Rating
  • Cad Crowd Top Product Design CompanyCad Crowd Top Product Design Company

Company

  • About Us
  • Solutions Overview
  • Testimonials
  • Inventor Stories
  • Blog
  • Video Library
  • FAQ
  • Careers & Internships

Services

  • Product Discovery
  • Product Design
  • Prototyping
  • Silicone Rubber
  • Manufacturing
  • Market Research
  • All Services

Industries

  • Medical Devices
  • Personal Care
  • Sports & Fitness
  • Product Packaging
  • IoT & Consumer
  • Our Work

Tools

  • Product Name Generator
  • Free US Trademark Search
  • AI Invention Idea Analyzer
  • US Patent Search
  • AI Product Idea Generator
  • Prototype Cost Calculator
  • All Free Tools

Get in Touch

  • 318-200-0526
  • 419 Dan Reneau Dr, Ruston, LA 71270
  • Mon–Fri, 10am–6pm Central
  • Contact Us
  • Book a Consultation
  • Service Areas

© Since 2015 by LA NPDT  ·  Privacy Policy · Terms & Conditions · Site index · Newsletter · Cookies · Returns · Shipping

LA NPDT on LinkedIn·Born in Louisiana, making impact worldwide.

  1. Home
  2. /
  3. Insights

How to Know If Your Idea Is Worth Pursuing

How to know if your idea is worth pursuing is a common question for inventors and entrepreneurs. Invention idea help is in this blog.

August 4, 2022·13 min read

Konstantin Dolgan

Written by Konstantin Dolgan, Ph.D., NPDP

Founder & CEO, Product Development Engineer

Published August 4, 2022 · Updated September 2, 2026

Key takeaways

  • If There Are People Willing To Pay For It. It’s well known that no company can survive without customers.
  • If There Are Similar Products On A Market. Let’s be clear on this. A new product is not necessarily a unique product.
  • If There Is A Problem Your Idea Is Solving. The world has to battle new challenges and realities from time to time.
  • If It Is Sufficient Market Size. Before committing to a project, you should ascertain that there is a niche market for the idea.
  • If You Have Time Or Will Be Able To Allocate Time To Do It. Successful entrepreneurs prioritize their business.

In this article

  1. 01
    If There Are People Willing To Pay For It
  2. 02
    If There Are Similar Products On A Market
  3. 03
    If There Is A Problem Your Idea Is Solving
  4. 04
    If It Is Sufficient Market Size
  5. 05
    If You Will Be Able To Make A Return On The Investment
  6. 06
    If You Have Time Or Will Be Able To Allocate Time To Do It
  7. 07
    The Takeaway
  8. 08
    Receive Pdp Example
  9. 09
    Thank you for choosing LA New Product Development Team for your New Product development plan.
  10. 10
    Thank you for choosing LA New Product Development Team for your Prior Art Search.
  11. 11
    Thank you for choosing LA New Product Development Team for your Prior Art Search.
  12. 12
    Thank you for choosing LA New Product Development Team for your Prior Art Search.
  13. 13
    Frequently asked questions
    • How can I tell if there is demand for my product idea?
    • Should I be concerned if a similar product already exists in the market?
    • What role does problem-solving play in identifying a viable product idea?
    • Why shouldn't I rely on friends' opinions about my product idea?
    • How can I make my product stand out from competitors?
  14. 14
    Five validation tests, ranked by cost per unit of confidence
  15. 15
    The arithmetic that kills most ideas before a single interview
  16. 16
    Signals that look like validation but are not
  17. 17
    When to walk away

Entrepreneurship can be quite tricky. For instance, you just spent long hours researching product ideas without success. Then, while walking your dog in the neighborhood, you screamed, I have an idea for an invention.

For a moment, you felt like Albert Einstein and were convinced it was your eureka moment. You rushed home to inform some friends about the idea, and they were favorably disposed to it. But after a few months of product development, things went south. The investment seemed to be a waste. So, how to know if your idea is worth pursuing?

The above scenario is often the fate of many entrepreneurs in the 21st century. As an entrepreneur, you should not assume that an idea is worth the investment because of your associates’ validations. Indeed, there are metrics to measure product viability.

To save you hours of regret and loss of investment, we’ve come up with a guide to help you know whether your product idea is a yay or nay. Similarly, this article serves as an invention idea help. So don’t hesitate to share with your pals.

If There Are People Willing To Pay For It

It’s well known that no company can survive without customers. In the same vein, great ideas can only thrive because people are willing to pay for the product. But then, before you test the customers’ willingness to pay for your product, you ought to identify your target audience.

If I have an idea for an invention, it could be targeted toward a particular gender or age bracket. Similarly, you could decide to sell to individuals or supply other businesses. Some developers prefer government agencies as their customers.

To determine if people are willing to buy your product, you might have to research. Fieldwork comes in handy at this stage on how to invent my idea.

It is common for many entrepreneurs to experiment with this phase with their friends. But your friends might not tell you that your product is not worth buying to massage your ego. Instead, they most likely give you a nod, which is largely unhelpful.

Therefore, you shouldn’t rely on friends’ opinions when you have an idea for an invention. Product developers ought to go out there and encourage people to be objective about their products.

If you discover many people are not willing to pay a stipulated price for your product, it is not to say that they do not need the product. Instead, you may only need to consider an alternative business strategy or model.

If There Are Similar Products On A Market

Let’s be clear on this. A new product is not necessarily a unique product. So, if I have an idea for an invention and discover a similar product is already in existence, it’s not the time to back off. In fact, such an existing product is only a validation that I’m on a profitable path.

The business world is full of stiff competition. Since one’s idea is similar to an existing product, I must learn how to invent my idea in such a manner as to outshine the competition. And to help market products effectively, Seth Godin’s Purple Cow strategy comes to mind.

You must have heard about the phrase “Purple Cow” at one time or another. How many times do you see a purple cow around? Rarely, right? Okay, that’s great. This same principle applies to product development. You probably can’t help your ideas being similar to another product in the market. However, you may put in more work to make your product stand out. And this is the essence of the “Purple Cow” concept. You should stand out from the crowd.

To beat the competition, you can apply the competitive position matrix. Brand perception is a subtle invention idea help. What picture would you like people to imagine when they hear your product’s name? What is that subtle distinction that makes your product stand out?

You could reduce product prices to shift people’s attention to you. But there must be a correspondingly high-quality product. You cannot afford to sacrifice quality for cheap products.

In the beginning, customers might be influenced by the low price, but this newly funded patronage will not endure for long. This is because customers are not just looking for affordable products. Quality tops their list when choosing desired products. Hence, I must ensure to produce quality products when I have an idea for an invention.

If There Is A Problem Your Idea Is Solving

The world has to battle new challenges and realities from time to time. And if the cliché, “necessity is the mother of invention,” is anything to go by, these problems provide opportunities for developers to exploit. Indeed, existing problems are a great inspiration for how to invent my idea.

Do you ever wonder why some innovators are more reckoned with than others? The secret lies in that these popular developers successfully solved human challenges. For instance, Elon Musk got his invention idea help from the need to have a healthier environment.

The United Nations has continually warned of the dangers of the Greenhouse effect and global warming. So to promote a paradigm shift from fossil fuels to sustainable energy, Tesla created electric cars. In 2020 alone, Tesla helped the world avoid 5.0 million metric tons of C02-equivalent emissions.

Problem-solving can be reactive or preventive. For example, if you are an avid researcher, you might discover a problem likely to occur in the future. To this end, you can get to work immediately to forestall such challenges. However, other times, you might not be able to predict a future occurrence. Hence, you might have to facilitate a suitable solution in the shortest time possible.

Now, the question that is probably bothering your mind is how to research the problems people face. Your research methodology depends solely on your target audience. For example, if you are trying to build products for companies in the textile industry, you can approach them to know their pain points.

Likewise, you may want to make the world a safer place to live by creating high-tech surveillance equipment. One thing is certain. When you approach several people in the same industry, they will likely have similar problems. So you can note the patterns and come up with a robust solution.

If It Is Sufficient Market Size

Before committing to a project, you should ascertain that there is a niche market for the idea. Of course, your product needs not to be beneficial to everyone. You can target a particular population and maximize profits. The world has a population of about 7.9 billion people. And different groups have specific needs. If you can position your brand as the go-to store in a particular market, you will gain more customers.

To lay emphasis, you don’t have to create generic products. There are specific groups that need special products. For example, you might not know that the LGBTQ+ community is estimated to spend over $3.7 trillion globally. Brands like TomboyX, therefore, came up with LGBTQ-inclusive underwear. The company raised over $25million in funding even without any fashion experience.

You could target the pet industry or over 2.7 billion active gamers globally. These are examples of big enough markets for your ideas to thrive.

If You Will Be Able To Make A Return On The Investment

Business financing comes in different ways. For example, some developers could sponsor their ideas with the little savings they’ve got. Likewise, loans from financial institutions, friends, and family are common options.

On your part, you might not be lucky to have sufficient savings or friends who could lend you some money. Therefore, pitching to investors might be the only option. But irrespective of the mode of finance, an idea must be able to bear financial fruits. Solving societal challenges is not enough. You ought to be making profits from your product investment.

Research readily comes to mind if you want to make returns on your investment. Prepare a comprehensive document stating your capital. Know how many raw materials costs. Also, the manufacturing equipment and salaries will gulp a substantial part of your capital.

Granted that your profits outweigh the investment, your idea is worth pursuing. Therefore, financing and investment returns are veritable ways to guide how to invent my idea.

If You Have Time Or Will Be Able To Allocate Time To Do It

Successful entrepreneurs prioritize their business. In infancy, product ideas require all the time you’ve got. Therefore, you must pay close attention to the product development process; otherwise, your idea is doomed to fail.

On average, it takes about 2-3 years to start making substantial profits on a product. Furthermore, your product can only be deemed successful after about a decade of consumer satisfaction. It is safe to conclude that time management influences my decision on how to invent my idea.

So if you are not ready to sacrifice a greater part of your early years for an idea, then it is not worth developing after all.

The Takeaway

Many companies fail not because they don’t have great ideas. Rather, they fail because they invest in products that people don’t want – at least not at the moment or in years to come. In entrepreneurship, customers are gods. They dictate the needed products. And you have to flow with the tide. If you have to shove a product down consumers’ throats, you might have to dump such an idea for a more acceptable product.

Remember that the objections above are not to frustrate your product development process. Rather, they are a means to ensure that your idea lives up to expectations. Accordingly, if I have an idea for an invention, I can always turn to this article for proper guidance.

We will be happy to help you as well. So, schedule a consultation with us to discuss your idea.

Three reasons why our clients love working with us:

If you ever thought of developing a new product, don’t wait any longer. Talk with one of our experts today.

Talk to Our Experts

  • Geopolitical Risk in New Product Development
  • Component Lifecycle Management: Designing for Obsolescence
  • Material Qualification Strategy: Reducing Risk Before Production
  • Bridging Digital and Physical Prototyping
  • Systems Thinking in Hardware Development
  • 3D (7)
  • ecommerce (1)
  • Education (230)
  • Inspiration (121)
  • Market Reports (4)
  • Media (17)
  • News (50)
  • none (61)
  • Stories (7)
  • Tech (27)
  • Tech Talk Podcast (31)
  • Time Management (1)
  • Uncategorized (109)
  • Words (62)

Receive Pdp Example

Please submit your contact info to receive an example of a new product development plan.

Thank you for choosing LA New Product Development Team for your New Product development plan.

If you have any questions or need assistance with your order, please don’t hesitate to contact us.

318-200-0526 | hello@lanpdt.com

Thank you for choosing LA New Product Development Team for your Prior Art Search.

Please fill out the form to submit your order.

Upon successful payment, you will receive an email with a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) and a questionnaire regarding your product idea.

Your privacy and security are paramount to us, so rest assured that your information will be handled with the utmost confidentiality.

Step 1: Fill in your contact and billing details.
Step 2: Review your order summary.
Step 3: Submit payment.

After your payment is processed, please check your email for the NDA and questionnaire. Completing these documents promptly will allow us to start your Prior Art Search without delay.

If you have any questions or need assistance with your order, please don’t hesitate to contact us.

318-200-0526 | hello@lanpdt.com

Thank you for choosing LA New Product Development Team for your Prior Art Search.

Please fill out the form to submit your order.

Upon successful payment, you will receive an email with a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) and a questionnaire regarding your product idea.

Your privacy and security are paramount to us, so rest assured that your information will be handled with the utmost confidentiality.

Step 1: Fill in your contact and billing details.
Step 2: Review your order summary.
Step 3: Submit payment.

After your payment is processed, please check your email for the NDA and questionnaire. Completing these documents promptly will allow us to start your Prior Art Search without delay.

If you have any questions or need assistance with your order, please don’t hesitate to contact us.

318-200-0526 | hello@lanpdt.com

Thank you for choosing LA New Product Development Team for your Prior Art Search.

Please fill out the form to submit your order.

Upon successful payment, you will receive an email with a Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA) and a questionnaire regarding your product idea.

Your privacy and security are paramount to us, so rest assured that your information will be handled with the utmost confidentiality.

Step 1: Fill in your contact and billing details.
Step 2: Review your order summary.
Step 3: Submit payment.

After your payment is processed, please check your email for the NDA and questionnaire. Completing these documents promptly will allow us to start your Prior Art Search without delay.

If you have any questions or need assistance with your order, please don’t hesitate to contact us.

318-200-0526 | hello@lanpdt.com

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell if there is demand for my product idea?

To determine demand, identify your target audience first. Then, research to see if people are willing to pay for your product. Avoid relying solely on friends' opinions, as they may not be objective. If many are unwilling to pay the stipulated price, consider an alternative business strategy or model, as they may still need the product.

Should I be concerned if a similar product already exists in the market?

No, discovering a similar product already exists can validate that you are on a profitable path. It suggests market demand. Your focus should then be on making your product stand out from the competition. This involves identifying subtle distinctions and ensuring high quality, not just low prices.

What role does problem-solving play in identifying a viable product idea?

Problem-solving is a great inspiration for new ideas. Successful innovators often solve human challenges. Your idea should address an existing problem, whether reactively or preventively. Researching the problems people face, for example, by approaching companies in a specific industry, helps identify these pain points and potential opportunities.

Why shouldn't I rely on friends' opinions about my product idea?

Relying on friends' opinions can be unhelpful because they might not be objective. They may provide a favorable response to massage your ego, rather than giving honest feedback that your product is not worth buying. Product developers should seek objective opinions from potential customers through fieldwork and research.

How can I make my product stand out from competitors?

To stand out, make your product distinctive, like the "Purple Cow" concept suggests. Apply a competitive position matrix and focus on brand perception. While reducing prices can attract initial attention, high quality is essential for long-term patronage. Customers prioritize quality, so ensure your product maintains it.

Five validation tests, ranked by cost per unit of confidence

How to validate a business idea comes down to buying evidence in the right order: cheapest and most disqualifying first. Each test below has a threshold that should be written down before you run it, because a threshold decided afterwards is just a rationalisation.

Test
Cost
Time
What counts as a pass
Competitive teardown and price scan
$200-$2k
1 week
A clear gap that is not simply a lower price
Problem interviews (15-20)
$1k-$5k
2-3 weeks
At least 60% describe an active workaround they built or bought
Priced landing page with real traffic
$2k-$6k
2-4 weeks
2-4% conversion to email or deposit from qualified traffic
Pre-order or crowdfunding test
$8k-$40k
6-10 weeks
Funding goal reached with < 40% coming from your own network
Pilot units with real users
$10k-$50k
6-12 weeks
Majority still using at day 30 and willing to pay again

Caption: run these in order. Each one is cheap relative to the stage it protects you from entering blind.

Founder evaluating a product concept at a workshop table with competitor teardown photos, sample parts and a notebook of validation criteria

The arithmetic that kills most ideas before a single interview

Before any customer research, run the margin test.

Estimate landed unit cost from a teardown of the nearest competitor, then work forward through the channel: for retail, the shelf price needs to be roughly four to five times the landed cost once distributor and retailer margins are taken. For direct-to-consumer, three times, because acquisition cost and returns eat the difference.

If the resulting price exceeds what people already pay in the category, the idea needs a design change or a different channel, not a better pitch.

Signals that look like validation but are not

  • Enthusiasm from friends, family or anyone who knows you built it.
  • Survey respondents saying they would buy it — stated intent overstates behaviour by a wide margin.
  • Social media engagement with no price attached; likes are free, deposits are not.
  • A large total addressable market figure with no identified first customer.
  • Investor interest that is contingent on traction you do not yet have.
  • A competitor's success in an adjacent category with different buyers.

When to walk away

Set kill criteria before spending, and honour them: no active workaround among interviewees, a landed cost that cannot clear the channel maths after two design passes, a dominant incumbent that can add your differentiator in a firmware update, or a regulatory path longer than your runway. Walking away at $10k is a good outcome; walking away at $200k is the same decision made expensively.

When an idea does clear these tests, the next spend is a structured product discovery sprint followed by rapid prototyping of the single riskiest technical assumption.

Frequently asked questions

How do you validate a business idea with no money?+

Start with the free tests: teardown and price research on existing products, 15-20 problem interviews, and a landing page with a real price. Together these cost a few hundred dollars and a few weeks, and they eliminate most ideas before any development spend.

How many customer interviews are enough to validate an idea?+

Around 15-20 conversations with genuine target buyers is usually where patterns stabilise. What matters is not the count but the content: you are looking for evidence of an existing workaround, not enthusiasm for your concept.

Is a crowdfunding campaign good validation?+

It is strong demand validation and weak product validation. A funded campaign proves people will pay a stated price, but it says nothing about whether the product can be manufactured at that price — which is why so many funded campaigns ship late or not at all.

How long should idea validation take?+

Six to twelve weeks for a physical product, running teardown, interviews and a priced traffic test in parallel where possible. Longer than that usually means the criteria for a pass were never defined.

Have a product idea you want built?

LA NPDT takes concepts from sketch to production: design, prototyping and manufacturing under one roof.

Talk to an engineer

Filed under:EducationInspirationWords

Services related to this guide

  • Product design servicesIndustrial design and CAD taken all the way to manufacturable files.
  • Rapid prototypingWorking prototypes in days, from 3D printing to vacuum casting.
  • Electronic design servicesSchematic, PCB layout, firmware and bring-up, through to production handoff.
  • Product development examplesReal projects we designed, prototyped and shipped.

Get in touch

Tell us what this is about

Share a few details about your question, partnership, or idea, and a member of the LA NPDT team will reply within one business day.

Optional context

What are you looking to accomplish? (optional)

What do you already have? (optional, tick any)

loading…

Your information stays confidential and is never shared.

Related articles

All articles
  • Product Development Companies in Louisiana: Where to Take an Idea

    Product Development Companies in Louisiana: Where to Take an Idea

    Where Louisiana inventors and manufacturers can get a product designed, prototyped and built — including the free state programs most people never hear about — and when to look out of state.

  • You used ChatGPT to develop a product idea. Now what?

    You used Chatgpt to develop a product idea. Now what?

    Blog · AI Product Development · 9 min read You used ChatGPT to develop a product idea. Now what? Real AI product development starts the morning after the chat ends. Here is how L

  • Design freeze: when to lock the design before tooling

    Design freeze: when to lock the design before tooling

    A design freeze is not a meeting where everyone agrees the CAD looks finished. It is the written decision that geometry, electronics, firmware, materials, and the BOM are stable enough to spend real money on tooling or a production-intent build.